Friday, October 17, 2014

Let's Calm Down. The Nexus 6 is not the Holy Grail.

www.pcworld.com

If there's one thing that really grinds my gears in the smartphone world, it's the crusade for a pure Android experience and glorifying the Nexus brand. On October 16th, Google announced the Nexus 6 phablet and the Nexus 9 tablet. Many in the tech world are instantly declaring this the best smartphone ever. But, and I cannot stress this enough, the Nexus 6 is equal or inferior to the Galaxy Note 4 in almost every way.

On many levels, these two devices are exactly the same. They both have the same processor and RAM and the same screen resolution with (basically) the same pixels per square inch. Both have the same size battery with equivalent fast charging capabilities. The Nexus 6 claims 6 hours of battery life after 15 minutes of charging and the Note 4 claims a half full battery after 30 minutes of charging.

But the Note 4 trumps the Nexus 6 in a few key areas: Camera, Multi-Tasking and Extra Features.


Camera

No one can argue the high quality of Samsung's camera optics in its flagship smartphones. On the flip side, no one can argue against Motorola's track record of mediocrity with smartphone cameras. The Nexus 6 will have a 13 megapixel camera with OIS while the Note 4 will have a 16 megapixel camera, also with OIS. It's not about those extra 3 megapixels, it's about the whole package; software, lenses, module, etc. I'll believe a Nexus phone can equal the picture quality of the Note 4 when I see it (or when pigs fly, first class).


Multi-Tasking

The new Android operating system, code-named Lollipop, is going to be awesome. You can not deny Google's vanilla Android experience is overall better than most, if not all, manufacture skins. But true, powerful multi-tasking has only been accomplished by Samsung, not Google. Samsung was able to do this by employing the "let's see what sticks" philosophy. It's definitely not the most elegant pathway to innovation, but it works. On the Galaxy Note 4, you can easily have two apps running at the same time on the same screen. Granted, this is not true for all applications, but all the important ones are covered like, Youtube, Chrome, Messaging, Facebook, Twitter, Hangouts, Maps and Calendar (among others).  Quite frankly, in an environment where every company is incorporating each other's best features into their own smartphones (and suing left and right), how has NO OTHER manufacture copied Samsung's Multi-Window approach??? And with so much screen space on the Nexus 6, this phone is screaming for some real Samsung multi-tasking.


Extra Features

The extra "fluff" of the Galaxy Note 4 starts with the S-Pen and includes such features as fingerprint scanning, heart rate monitor, Air Gestures, Eye Tracking, Tool Box, One Hand Usability and others. The Nexus 6 has none of these features. Even the iPhone 6 Plus can stand up to fingerprint scanning and One Hand Usability. Nexus fanatics might argue "Who really needs that fluff?" But I believe in a more open mentality of "Why Not?" 

www.technobuffalo.com

Conclusion

As a disclaimer, I have not purchased a Galaxy Note 4 yet and I am not saying the Galaxy Note 4 is the best smartphone that is or ever will be. I just want to make sure people don't wait blindly for a Nexus 6 device that cannot truly standout from the competition.

The iPhone 6 Plus. If only......

www.techradar.com
I love the design of the iPhone 6 Plus. I don't understand why some tech experts and bloggers are criticizing the two plastic antenna bands on the back of the device. For me, they just help the 6 Plus stand out from the competition. I also love the software. iOS 8 is incredibly fluid and responsive with a superior App Store to Google Play (though not by much).

But, as a Galaxy Note 3 owner, there are specific features I am very hesitant to sacrifice for a return to Apple-Land.

First the missing features I could forsake without loosing much sleep:

Removable Battery

My wallet is home to me IDs, credit cards, Panera Reward Card and now my backup battery. The GN3 battery is the perfect size for a man's wallet. The Note 3 has a great battery by itself, but I do admit my Gear 2 Neo drains the battery faster that I would like. Having a backup makes me completely worry free. 

***One caveat though, the Galaxy Note 4's battery is very rectangular, so it cannot fit in a traditional wallet. Still, replacing the battery is far quicker than plugging in a portable charger and waiting to refill the battery.   
www.phonearena.com

Micro SD Card

I can purchase a 64GB iPhone 6 Plus on contract for $400 or I can purchase a Galaxy Note 4 with 32GB for $300 and get a 32GB micro SD card on Amazon for $15!

S-Pen

The S-Pen is one of those features you like having because it's their just in case. You don't really ever need it, but I like the idea of taking quick notes and jotting down ideas with the pen. But this feature is not blocking my iPhone return. 


These features are....


Camera

www.gizmag.com
Why Apple, why??? There is no need to make a statement saying "Pixels aren't everything." HTC is trying this and all I see is a beautifully design One M8 that I would never buy in 1,000,000,000,000 years. 

Don't get me wrong, in outdoor or well-lit areas, any modern smartphone takes great pictures. But even in 'ideal' conditions, a lack of megapixels incredibly hampers one important aspect of photography, zooming. If you're just taking pictures and immediately printing them out, more power to you, enjoy your iPhone 6 Plus. But if you plan on showing pictures on your tablet or desktop computer or want to zoom and then print, then you need pixels. This became apparent in a recent CNET article comparing the cameras of the Galaxy Note 4, iPhone 6 Plus and the LG G3.


The section of this article titled "100 Percent Crop" directly demonstrates the weakness of an 8 megapixel sensor. Maybe I'm just spoiled by a 13 megapixel camera on the Galaxy Note 3, but looking at 6 Plus photos in review articles, I can almost 'feel' the lack of pixels. There is an extra degree of sharpness missing which I do not think I can sacrifice for top tier design.

Quad HD

This is very much a subtle point, but it really grinds my gears. I have wholeheartedly enjoyed a 1080p screen for almost a year. Now, as Quad HD smartphone displays begin their rise, Apple's breakout phablet is staying with 1080p (as is Sony's Xperia Z3, for that matter).  I don't like that. I don't like that one bit. Particularly because Apple will create their own Quad HD display by next year!

www.cnet.com

Conclusion

Even with these concerns, I did not dive head first and pre-order the Galaxy Note 4. I need to feel the device in my hand and see the software features. I have already made several trips to the Apple Store to hold the 6 Plus (and a few more trips to come). I'm going to take my time making a decision that affects my next two years of life, and you should too.